Tara Noble and her works
Contents of the Brain, experiences of living in Turkey and traveling and blogging about Turkey and Istanbul
Culture of “ayıp”: What will the neighbors think?
Categories: Uncategorized

As you may know if you are a regular reader, I rarely go on rants. I try to maintain as positive and optmistic a stance in my writing as I possibly can. And it’s hardly a put-on. I am mostly happy here in Turkey and that’s more than a lot of people.

Lately, however, certain thorns-in-my-side have been making it a bit uncomfortable for me to breathe. Of these disturbances, this whole culture of ayıp is the hardest for me to deal with.

Ayıp literally means “shame or disgrace”, but it also means “fault or defect”. But the whole idea surrounding “ayıp” is deeply entrenched in Turkish society. The fear of it guides peoples’ every-day actions. Beyond a mere system of societal taboo, it is a way of thinking that is passed from generation to generation. What the neighbors will think is extremely important. It is instilled into young children who will one day pass it on to their own offspring if they cannot break the cycle. Allow me to give you a few example of what I am talking about.

I would describe all of my foreign friends living here as very respectful people. All of them do their best to assimilate into Turkish culture. My friend Raquel lives in a neighborhood on the European side and she is deeply passionate about it, even supporting the football team liker a true fanatic and attending the local hamam. But even she is not safe from the scrutiny that is ayıp. Recently, a Turkish friend of hers told her that a picture she had posted of a man at the seaside wearing an undershirt and swimming trunks was offensive. She was obviously puzzled by this as well as frustrated.

Turks often think of people from other cultures as being too laid-back about things and Americans are accused of this all the time. We are simply too relaxed and this is wrong. Recently, I got my boyfriend into trouble accidentally.

Unfortunately, when it is obvious to a Turks that the offender is foreign, they turn to lash out on their Turkish mate instead. Twice in one week, I, in my heathenly relaxed state, committed ayıp, and the boyfriend took the rap.
Once was when we were in the grocery store. We had just come from the gym and I was parched. As we walked, I popped open my 7-Up and gulped it down. People looked at me as though I had just taken off my clothes. I couldn’t figure out what the big deal was. Back home, people routinely give their kid a candy bar to placate them as the shop and then hand the empty wrapper to the cashier. It’s commonplace. But in Turkey, this is major ayıp, aparently. And someone was on the verge of lecturing the boyfriend about it, too, but we hauled out of there.

The next night, we went to see a movie. The theatre was mostly empty. I had taken off my flip flops and put my clean feet on the back of the seat in front of me. There was no one in that row save five seats down. Again, people are forever putting their feet up wherever they please in America, and usually with their shoes on, even. You see it in sitcoms all the time. People flop down on the couch after work, with their boots on. This is incredibly offensive in Turkish culture.
The point is that some guy, five seats down, totally attacked the boyfriend at intermission. It got very heated. This guy was on the war path. Ayıp makes people very uptight. He wanted to take up a vote from the theatre goers if he was right to be offended by what I had done. He even offered to ask security’s take on it. In other words, he threatened to have us thrown out. I had dutifully taken my feet down as soon as it began. I am not looking to start any trouble, after all, and I especially do not want the boyfriend to be in a position where he has to defend me. That’s a slippery slope because even though he may agree with me, we are in THIS culture and we have to play by THEIR rules.

Single women often have their own difficult lines to toe. Two of my female friends, both Turkish, have been subjected to scrutiny by their kapıcıs. A kapıcı is the doorman of a building. He sometimes does the cleaning of the hallways, collects packages, changes light bulbs, that kind of thing. They are almost always incredibly poor, uneducated men from some god-forsaken village and this is the best work they can ask for in Istanbul.
Anyway, when my friend Filiz ecently moved into her building, the kapıcı said to her, “The girl who used to live here was so nice. She never had any male guests.” You can see what the implication is there. My other friend, Hale, suffered the same comments from her kapıcı. In her case, the kapıcı and his wife live on the first floor and whenever she comes home, they peek out the window to see if she is alone.

Speaking of kapıcıs, the boyfriend had a silly kapıcı in the building of his old music school in Ankara. Every year around the Kurban Bayram (Sacrifice Holiday), he would come around asking for donations. Even though he was dirt poor, he was trying to buy an animal to sacrifice so that he could show the people back home that he was a success. Naturally Allah excuses those who are too poor to take care of themselves, but this guy was suffering under the yoke of ayıp. It would have been ayıp for him not to send that meat and he couldn’t bear that kind of shame.

Americans are routinely accused of being liberal dirty hippies. The fact that we like to take our shoes off at the park and walk barefoot in the grass is absolutely appalling to most Turks and shows how loose our morals are.

And speaking of loose morals, I feel so sorry for all of my Russian girlfriends. I learned very quickly how Russian women are viewed by some Turkish people. Turkish women, in large part, despise them. Unfortunately, in the 80s, a lot of Russian women entered Turkey illegally and worked as prostitutes. A lot of them ended up wrecking homes and stealing husbands. To this day, they are regarded skeptically and sometimes even called whores outright. If you ask me, that sort of judgmentalism is what ought to be considered ayıp. But what do I know? I’m just a dirty hippie American with loose morals. (sigh)

Categories: Uncategorized -

8 Comments to “Culture of “ayıp”: What will the neighbors think?”

  1. Katie says:

    Oh god, you hit it right on the head. Don’t get me started about all the “ayip” comments I’ve heard over the years. Ugh…

    After all these years being married into a Turkish family, I still don’t understand why people care so much about what other people think. One of the more frustrating parts of it all, I think.

    Great piece!

  2. Graeme says:

    This is why Turkey shouldn’t be part of the EU. They are anything but European.

  3. me says:

    Graeme, the majority of Turks would not disagree with you on either score. The whole EU membership idea has lost popularity in the greater society. They do not claim to be European. Nor are they Middle Eastern. Turkish identity is a force all of its own, and they like it that way!

  4. legomego says:

    I am a turkish gal (born in Bulgaria, then 20+ years in Canada, and in terms of lifestyle, very Canadian). After a visit to Turkey this summer, I am itching to maybe spend a year or two in Istanbul.

    It’s so beautiful: the sites, the food, the thought of a not-so-cold winter, my heritage fully available to discover. I would love to go and enrich my turkish speaking (in Turkey everyone thought I was a tourist who’d learned turkish, which broke my heart), and fully explore and inhabit turkish culture.

    I am set on carrying out this idea, except for not looking forward to things like the “ayip” culture and ridiculously curious and gossping neighbours (I lived in Turkey for one year when I was 6, and even at age I knew this existed), male machoness, status of women, etc. I am so stuck because I have a love here and we’re at a point where we can take our relationship to the next level (moving in, thinking about marriage), but also feel this is the only time in my life when I can do something like this. Eeek!

    Anyway, thanks for sharing your thoughts and feelings about Turkey…

  5. Mumsy says:

    I am so bad about stuff like that, I am sure I would be offending people right and left over there, you know me I am a hillbilly at heart and I think I had better just stay here where I can munch on my box of Goobers as I shop and try on 100 different kinds of flip flops only to opt to going barefoot the rest of the day….yup…I had better stay right here where I can live in La La Land…ha! But, God bless you for making it this long with all of those restraints…you are forgetting…I KNOW you and I know that has got to be hard always having to watch every move you make and wondering if you are doing the “right” thing or not…I will spare Baris the embarrassment of having me over THERE…and welcome him HERE, maybe he and I will take our shoes off and walk through the park who knows, I am more than willing to share my Goobers…

  6. Monique says:

    I don’t understand the ayıp of opening stuff in the shop before you’ve paid for it. I mean I understand it, as I tend to frown upon it here (sorry T), but M always tries to open up a chocolate bar or something while we’re waiting in line at the supermarket, so where did he learn that behaviour, if not in Turkey? I always give him a ‘çok ayıp!’ if he does it. I do put my feet on the cinema seats though.

  7. Elif says:

    Hi Tara,

    Your blog overall is both very interesting and funny to read.
    I m a Turkish girl living abroad for 10 years, sometimes I have problems to explain some concepts about Turkish culture to my friends and family. Your writings will be much helpful.
    I would think that Turkish people would be much more tolerant to foreigners. As you are American, they would not judge you or expect you to behave the way they want, as they could do to a regular Turkish citizen -maybe I’m wrong-.
    After I left Turkey for France, I felt much more free to do what ever I want, the way I want. I understand your frustration. Probably in Turkey you can t come up as an individual as easier as in as America, it s all about what will people say. And obviously as you clearly showed in “kapici” case, people like to stick their noses in others businesses, so you have to keep the image nice and clear.
    I live in Japan right now, and they have an even harder “ayip” concept here, social pressure is much heavier but most of the time, they are like:”stupid gaijin (foreigner) she doesnt know how to do, how to behave”. Most of the time I am happy to be the stupid gaijin, all this etiquette, 100 different layers of respect, is too hard to get.
    Will keep reading !

  8. I am from the US and about to move to Istanbul with my Turkish husband…I wonder what kind of trouble I’ll get him in with my loose morals…

Leave a Reply